Not everyone is charmed by Marianne Williamsons insurgent, self-help candidacy.
Both skeptics and supporters alike are enamored with Williamsons longshot bid for the Democratic presidential nomination, from her quirky stances to herpassionate deliveries. And although her polling remains low, shes been the subject of social media adoration after each of her debate performances, even from credible journalists.
Though many Americans are just now learning about Williamson for the first time, she enjoyed a long career as an author, spiritualist, and self-help guru to the stars, whereshe promoted questionable and even dangerous scientific, or pseudoscientific, ideas.
Those are beginning to get attention in the media, but one group has already been delivering sharp rebukes: disability advocates.
#CripTheVote is an online effort to hold Williamson accountable. The movement, which is nonpartisan, works to engagedisabled people on policies and practices important to the disability community.
When disability activists saw Williamsons warm debate reception Tuesday night, they set to work reminding the world of her past actions regarding the AIDS crisis and her stance towards medicine, illness, and disabilities.
If you ever read an article saying that I told people with AIDS they didn't have to take their medicine because positive thinking would cure it; or that I ever told people who got sick that negative thinking caused it; please know both those things are complete and utter lies.
— Marianne Williamson (@marwilliamson) June 23, 2019
Alice Wong, Andrew Pulrang, and Gregg Beretan, who started the hashtag, are profoundly concerned that the public can so blithely enjoy Williamson on the stage.
I object to her view that sickness, illness, and disability is an illusion that can be wished away by positive-thinking, says Wong. No amount of prayer or forgiveness by me will ever help me walk again. Her anti-science beliefs harm millions of people with depression, other mental health disabilities, or HIV/AIDS that take medications and other treatments in order to survive.
Willamson came to prominence after Oprah championed her 1992 book A Return to Love: Reflections on the Principles of A Course in Miracles, a reinterpretation of the 1960s new-age hitA Course in Miracles by Helen Shuchman. A Return to Love launched Williamson to self-help stardom. At the height of her fame, she received a Los Angeles Times profile that branded her a guru to the stars.
A Course in Miracles and A Return to Love contain a healthy mix of pseudoscience and new-age philosophy, but the most destructive idea in activists eyes is that both Shuchman and Williamson believe the world is an illusion, and so sickness and pain are also illusions. Only love is real. Illness, disease, and disabilities arent.
In the book, Williamson details how she facilitated bizarre dialogues between AIDS patients and their disease. In one passage, the virus responds, If I was, as they say, out to get you, dont you think youd be dead by now? Im not able to kill, harm, or make you sick. You give me the power you should give to God.
In the Times cover story, the reporter watched Williamson tell a support group with the HIV virus, your soul is not sick.
Williamson founded the Los Angeles Center for Living, an organization that purported to focus on healing patients with terminal illnesses including AIDS. Her co-founder, Louise Hay, claimed to have cured her cervical cancer through alternative healing.
I think disabled people, especially activists, actually have less fear of the outright bullies everyone can see, than we have for the harm that comes unintentionally from kind people who are supposed to be our allies. And Marianne Williamson kind of fits that, said Andrew Pulrang.
Activists say Williamson had a direct hand in directing AIDS patients away from proper treatment and towards prayer and meditation.
Given her biography, it seems they have a point.
I worked in HIV starting in 1989. I ran the Southern CA AIDS Hotline in the 90s. The number of people who were convinced by her & Louise Hay that their illness was the dis-ease from their own internalized whatever caused more people to die blaming themselves than I can count.
— Dvorah Landsman (@faithlandsman) July 31, 2019
It isnt just the AIDS crisis that Williamson met with her brand of spirituality.
Activists who spoke with the Daily Dot pointed to previous statements Williamson has made about vaccines, antidepressants, and other scientifically proven forms of medical treatment.
One particular detail that came up repeatedly was Williamsons tweet on the 29th anniversary of the ADA that praised Opportunity Village, a sheltered workshop where disabled people work in a segregated environment and are paid below the minimum wage.
Today is the 29th anniversary of the Americans with Disabilities Act. I have found, visiting such places as the Center for the Blind & Opportunity Village (for the intellectually impaired) in Las Vegas, NV, that https://t.co/4i3aWw4xH9
— Marianne Williamson (@marwilliamson) July 27, 2019
This is a sheltered workshop. Sheltered workshops pay disabled people well below minimum wage in segregation. Theres federal legislation that just passed the House to outlaw subminimum wage. Its not impossible for it to pass in the Senate.
How are you this clueless?
— Sara Luterman (@slooterman) July 27, 2019
Wow, you're supporting a sheltered workshop that exploits workers with disabilities by segregating them and paying pennies on the dollar.
Congrats on yet again illustrating your blatant ableism.
— Sarah Blahovec (@Sblahov) July 27, 2019
Disability activist Sarah Blahovec adds, I have a life-threatening chronic illness that is incurable and mental health conditions. Ive been approached by people who talk of faith healing and downplay the importance of medical science in my well-being, and people who try to convince me that essential oils or energy healing can treat a condition that Im getting organ surgery for next week and had to tediously manage with a variety of medications for over a decade I draw a line when someone uses their influence to convince others that alternative or spiritual healing is more important than medical treatment.
The #CripTheVote hashtag doesnt just want to shine a light on Williamson. They want to use her bad examples to talk about what they want to see in a presidential candidate.
Disability activist Neal Carter says that a presidential candidate should be willing to bring disabled people to the table and make sure [the table] is accessible.
Activist Reyma McCoy McDeid adds, Id like to see candidates have actual disabled people on staff providing guidance and expertise on policy that impacts disabled people.
Willamsons past has provided an opportunity for disability activists like Wong and the other leaders of #CripTheVote to expand the dialogue around the disability community and disability policy.
However, its leaders stress that their hashtag was here long before Williamson came back to public prominence and they plan to be around long after.
Im humbled by the breadth of knowledge and wisdom our participants frequently share on policy, politics, and disability issues, said Wong. I feel that politicization starts when you realize youre part of a larger community and movement and its my hope that #CripTheVote encourages disabled people to express themselves and find power in one another.
- Marianne Williamson tells a child the hard truth about her cat: It died
- Marianne Williamsons old tweets about medicine are back to haunt her
- Marianne Williamsons impassioned defense of Flint was her breakout moment
Got five minutes? Wed love to hear from you. Help shape our journalism and be entered to win an Amazon gift card by filling out our 2019 reader survey.